Field Insider
Centre-backUSAMajor League Soccer

Kevin O'Toole

Squad depthNew York City FC · 27 yrsRotation

Profile

Full nameKevin O'Toole
PositionCentre-back
NationalityUSA
Age27
Date of birth14 Dec 1998
Height178 cm
Shirt number#22
ClubNew York City FC
More about K. O'Toole →
Centre-backalso played MID

Season stats

Full career & schedule →
17
Appearances
0
Goals
0
Assists
1264
Minutes

Domestic-league season · New York City FC.

Performance data · by competition

CompetitionAppsGAMinMatch
Major League Soccer10009196.37

Scout report

Squad depthCentral defender

K. O'Toole is a 27-year-old central defender at New York City FC, rated 32.9 overall by Field Insider's model, ranking 275th of 486 on scout potential in the Major League Soccer. In his prime years, he has been a rotation option this season (54% of available minutes). His defensive output reads 2.49 tackles, blocks and interceptions per 90. Below: strengths, watch-points, market-value outlook and the latest transfer news on O'Toole.

Judged on this season alone, O'Toole graded 15 — a workmanlike campaign that ranks 96th of 122 of the 122 centre-backs in the Major League Soccer, on 3 clean sheets and 2.492 defensive actions per 90.

Year-on-year, that's a drop on last season (Season 30 → 15). Over the 5 seasons on record his form has trended upward, peaking in 2025/26.

On long-term talent our Rating reads 33, 63rd of 122 of the 122 centre-backs in the Major League Soccer. At 27 O'Toole is in his prime years, and a market index of 6.2 reflects that trajectory.

From the career report
Read the full career report →

Below his 2025/26 peak but holding a solid level — the platform for a return is there.

Peak: 2025/26Holding levelBreakout: 2025/26Injury-hit 2025/26
Current potential63rd of 122 centre-backs · Major League SoccerCurrent season96th of 122 centre-backs · Major League Soccer96th-best centre-back in the Major League Soccer275th in the Major League Soccer · potential63rd-highest potential centre-back in the Major League Soccer
32.9
Ratingi
63rd of 122 centre-backs
14.7
Seasoni
below regular-starter level
54%
Minutes
rotation minutes
2.49
Def. actions / 90
moderate defensive volume

Output in context · New York City FC finished 8th of 15 · a mid-table side

17
Apps
2.49
Def. / 90
21
Tackles
10
Interceptions
3
Clean sheets

2.49 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90 — moderate defensive volume, with 3 clean sheets across 17 appearances.

Watch points

  • Game time. Only 54% of available minutes — needs a settled run to prove the level.
  • Level. Rates below a nailed-on top-tier starter on our model.

Outlook

With a Rating of 32.9, O'Toole carries the 63rd-highest potential of the centre-backs in the Major League Soccer of 122. Defensively he reads as moderate defensive volume (2.49 tackles, blocks & interceptions per 90). In the prime window — at or near peak market value, so the next two seasons are the ones to cash in or build around.

Generated from Field Insider's rating model · AI-written analysis to follow.

Season statistics

Bars = where he ranks among centre-backs in the Major League Soccer with 600+ minutes this season.

Shooting

Goals0
Shots on target2
Shots3

Passing

Assists0
Chances created7
Passes720
Pass accuracy88%

Possession

Successful dribbles2
Dribble success16.7%
Duels won42
Duels won %46.2%
Fouls won6

Defending

Tackles21
Interceptions10
Blocks4
Fouls committed9
Penalties conceded1

Yellow/red cards

Yellow cards2
Red cards0

Transfer news

No transfer news found for this player.